1st Round

04-16-2009
Dave Trochlell--Accept

Based on this excellent and comprehensive report, my own research, and the testimony of WEGU experts, I'm totally convinced this was a first-cycle Western Gull, and without any indications of hybridization with another large Larus gull species.

04-18-2009
Sturts --Accept

Excellent description and photos leave no doubt as the correct identification.

26 April 2009
Hardy--Accept

Overall patterning/color, as well as size/structure, consistent with Western.

04-28-2009
chuck trost--Accept

I was a bit bothered by the very dark chest and the relatively thiness of the bill, but must admit that it closely resembles the first cycle WEGU #31,4 in Howell and Dunn.

4/28/2009
Darren Clark--Accept

Written description and photographs are convincing.

5-13-09
Carlisle--Accept

looks good

05-28-2009
Doug Ward--Accept

Extremely detailed and thorough report supporting photos of a classic 1st year Western (Larus occidentalis). Good comparisons to likely species as well as potential hybrids. Excellent report.