1st Round Voting Comments

Record #: 52-B-06

Short-billed Dowitcher

ACCEPT: 7 Accept, 0 Reject

 

###############

11-19-2006.

Shirley Sturts -- Accept

Well documented included description of tertials markings of a short-billed.

###############

11-25-2006.

Chuck Trost -- Accept

Multiple observers, good description of tertial markings on a juvenile dowitcher, flight call heard.

###############

11-26-2006.

Dave Trochlell -- Accept

The description of this juvenile dowitcher's tertial pattern clearly indicates that is a Short-billed Dowitcher. I accept this candidate as a record with no reservations.

###############

11/29/06.

Cliff Weisse -- Accept

Relevant field marks included in description.

###############

11/29/06.

Charles Swift -- Accept

Diagnostic description. (Perhaps this species should be removed from the review list as it appears to be annual in small numbers).

###############

12-04-2006.

Carlisle -- Accept

2 critical field marks (call and tertial markings) well described.

###############

01-02-2007.

dumroese -- Accept

Good description of expected SBDO tertial markings.

###############