Voting Comments
Record #: 9-B-99
Ruddy Turnstone
1st Round: 7-0
ACCEPT
|
1st Round |
| 02-17-2007. Shirley Sturts -- Accept With the distictive markings on this shorebird, it would be hard to mix it up with other shorebirds, especially when still in breeding plumage. The description of the orange, black and white patterning and orange legs convinced me. According to the guides an adult could still be in breeding plumage on September 1, although looking worn as the observer mentioned. |
| 2-19-07. Carlisle -- Accept details sufficient |
| 2/21/2007. Cliff Weisse -- Accept Written description includes excellent detail of black and rusty pattern of upperparts and facial pattern that are very distinctive and diagnostic of breeding Ruddy Turnstone. |
| 03-05-2007. Dave Trochlell -- Accept This report describes an adult Ruddy Turnstone in near-breeding condition, and was convincing enough for me. |
| 03-12-2007. chuck trost -- Accept description adequate, if minimal as to date and time. But the orange legs and vack color are hard to mix up. |
| 5/4/2007. Charles Swift -- Accept Good description of a distinctive species. (** I'm not sure if the attribution is correct on this report.) |
| 26 July 2007. Hardy -- Accept Well described individual in alternate plumage. |