1st Round

8 May 2010
Weisse – Accept

05-08-2010
Darren Clark--Accept

That description can't be of any bird other than a Rose-breasted Grosbeak, a pretty common vagrant (maybe one of the most common birds on the review list) in Idaho. The date is perfect as well.

05-09-2010
Sturts--Accept

Description fits that of these easily identified birds.

23 May 2010
Hardy--Accept

Report describes diagnostic fieldmarks of the distinctive adult male.

5-28-10
chuck trost--Accept

While not an in-depth description, the bird is remarkably colorful. No evidence of hybrid with BHGR

06-26-2010
Dave Trochlell--Accept

I'm convinced.

6-26-10
Carlisle--Accept

tough to mistake a male RBGR