Voting Comments
Record #: 69-B-06
Red Phalarope
1st Round: (7-0)
ACCEPT
|
1st Round |
| 07-11-2007. Sturts -- Accept Evidence provided convinced me that this was a Red Phalarope. |
| 7/14/07. Cliff Weisse -- Accept The description is sufficient to confirm the identification of Red Phalarope. |
| 07-15-2007. Dave Trochlell -- Accept The description and timing are right for REPH, but the brevity of the observation gave me some unease. I also wanted to know the distance Mike was from the bird. I didn't see that information anywhere in the report. |
| 07-16-2007. chuck trost -- Accept Even though seen only briefly, it was well documented. The behavior and time of year sound good too. |
| 7-29-07. Carlisle -- Accept Thorough description |
| 6 August 2007. Hardy -- Accept This was a brief sighting, but I found the report to be convincing, especially because of Haldeman's style of leading the reader step-by-step through his decision-making process. The date is well within the range for interior fall sightings noted by Paulson 1993. |
| 10/2/07. Charles Swift -- Accept Well described even if a brief sighting and the date supports Red over Red-necked. |