1^st Round
( Accept, Reject)

05-21-2008.

Sturts -- Accept

It would have been nice to see the video but the report included diagnostic field marks and eliminated similar species.

11-16-2008

Weisse -- Accept

Detailed description includes field marks that confirm the identification of Palm Warbler including tail pumping behavior.

11-18-2008.

Darren Clark -- Accept

Description of plumage, structure, and behavior are consistent with Palm Warbler. It would be nice to see the video.

11-20-2008.

chuck trost -- Accept

Good description and tail movements diagnostic.

11-21-2008.

Dave Trochlell -- Accept

The rare bird report covered the main field marks of the species and was convincing. It was also notable that the observer saw the bird on two consecutive days.

11-25-08.

Carlisle -- Accept

Well described

27 November 2008.

Hardy -- Accept

Describes diagnostic tail-wagging and yellow undertail coverts contrasting with whitish underparts.