Voting Comments
Record #: 71-B-07
Northern Parula
1st Round: 7-0
ACCEPT
|
1st Round |
| 010-02-2007. Sturts -- Accept This report includes the field markds needed to identify this bird as a Northen Parula. Although I can't see the eye-arcs in the photographs they are mentioned in the description and the breastband can be seen. I assume it is quality of the photographs that are the problem. |
| 10/3/2007. Cliff Weisse -- Accept Description and photos confirm ID of Northern Parula. In addition this individual has maroon spots on the sides of the breast, visible in the photos, that are absent on #58-B-07 confirming that his is a different individual. One of the photos of #58-B-07 (the top one on the page) does show a hint of a spot but its extent and location appear different and it isn't visible in the other photos. |
| 010-05-2007. Dave Trochlell -- Accept Well documented and very convincing. |
| 010-06-2007. chuck trost -- Accept Good description and great pics. |
| 18 October 2007. Hardy -- Accept Photos adequate to show diagnostic fieldmarks - yellow throat and breast, white belly, dark breastband. |
| 04-16-2008. Doug Ward -- Accept When I first noticed the date and location of this record, I assumed it was the same bird as record 58-B-07, but after reading this excellent account, I too am convinced this was a second individual. |
| 04-29-2008. Darren Clark -- Accept The photographs alone are adequate to eliminate all other species. |