1st Round Voting Comments
Record #: 35-B-05
Little Gull
ACCEPT: 7 Accept, 0 Reject
###############
010-11-2006.
Shirley Sturts -- Accept
Excellent description and photographs
###############
10/12/06.
Cliff Weisse -- Accept
Photos are definitive.
###############
010-12-2006.
Chuck Trost -- Accept
Good photo and description. I saw this bird too and have no doubt as to its identity.
###############
010-25-2006.
Dave Trochlell -- Accept
I accept this record candidate without any reservations, thanks to the excellent documentation presented by Cliff.
###############
11-4-06.
Carlisle -- Accept
Report and photos good.
###############
11/14/2006.
Charles Swift -- Accept
Almost too easy - diagnostic dark wing linings make for an easy ID if well seen.
###############
01-02-2007.
dumroese -- Accept
Good description of underwings substantiated with a photo, although this sounds more like a third winter rather than second summer bird.
###############