1^st Round
(7 Accept, 0 Reject)

05-21-2008.

Sturts -- Accept

The report, including and excellent photograph leaves no doubt about the correct identification.

11-16-2008

Weisse -- Accept

photos confirm the identification of Hooded Warbler

11-18-2008.

Darren Clark -- Accept

Although the written description is fairly weak, the photographs are unmistakable.

11-20-2008.

chuck trost -- Accept

Fair description and excellent photos.  

11-21-2008.

Dave Trochlell -- Accept

I reviewed this record last year for NAB. Then, as now, I was totally convinced of the identification because of the good images, though no description of the bird was offered.

11-25-08.

Carlisle -- Accept

great photos

28 November 2008.

Hardy -- Accept

Good photos of adult male.