1st Round

15 December 2009
Weisse – Accept

Field marks included in the written descriptions are sufficient to support the identification of Hoary Redpoll.

12-16-2009
Doug Ward--Accept

All key points are made for this species, including bill structure – sounds as if this individual was clearly on the diagnostic end of the Hoary Redpoll spectrum.

12-18-2009
Dave Trochlell--Accept

I'm convinced.

12-27-2009
Darren Clark--Accept

Descriptions were good and touched on the key points.

21 December 2009
Hardy--Accept

Diagnostic fieldmarks noted.

12-20-2009
Sturts --Accept

Well described and compared with common Redpoll.

1-31-10
Carlisle--Accept

convincing descriptions