Voting Comments
Record #: 10-B-01
Golden-winged Warbler
1st Round: 6-1
2nd Round: 7-0
|
1st Round |
2nd Round |
| 08-12-2007. Sturts -- Accept Good description, similar warbler eliminated |
01-29-2009.
I'm staying with my first round vote for the same reasons. |
| 08-18-2007. Dave Trochlell -- Accept The description accounts for the major GWWA field marks and seems to eliminate the possibility of a Blue-winged X Golden-winged Warbler hybrid. |
01-31-2009.
I'll stay the course in my decision to accept this record. |
| 23 August 2007. Hardy -- Accept Description of black throat, eye mask and large yellow wing patch eliminates all other species. |
28 January 2009.
Same comments as first round. |
| 8/23/07. Cliff Weisse -- Reject, specific identification not established I'm rejecting this record because the report was written one month after the sighting and it doesn't say whether the description is from notes or memory. I'd like to know how the report was prepared. |
1/28/09.
This is an easy species to identify and the description, despite being written a month later, rules out other species. |
| 09-06-2007. chuck trost -- Accept The yellow on the head and wing, plus the face pattern sound right to me. |
02-02-2009.
The description eliminates other species for me, and it was carefully watched for four minutes. |
| 11-04-2007. Carlisle -- Accept Good description |
2-3-09.
no change from round 1 |
| 02/11/2008. Darren Clark -- Accept Although I was skeptical at the time of hearing about this bird. The report seems to support the identification as Golden-winged Warbler and eliminates other species. |
02-06-2009.
The report is well-written and eliminates similar species. |