1st Round Voting Comments

Record #: 7-A-06

Glossy Ibis

ACCEPT: 7 Accept, 0 Reject

 

###############

010-11-2006.

Shirley Sturts -- Accept

Excellent photographs and description are consistent with the Glossy Ibis.

###############

10/12/06.

Charles Swift -- Accept

Good description.

###############

010-12-2006.

Chuck Trost -- Accept

Careful observation and description. The first and second photos were convincing - facial skin and eye color appear to be that of a GLIB in alternate plumage.

###############

10/13/06.

Cliff Weisse -- Accept

Photo number one, along with the description of the iris as dark are sufficient to confirm the ID of Glossy Ibis. Since the observer is not certain there were two birds present I vote to accept the record of one, not two, Glossy Ibis.

###############

010-26-2006.

Dave Trochlell -- Accept

A special thank you to Sasha Keyel for an excellent report. He provided very thorough and compelling written and photographic evidence that nicely supports this record.

###############

11-4-06.

Carlisle -- Accept

Photos and report good.

###############

01-02-2007.

dumroese -- Accept

I liked the good comparison of Glossy vs. White-faced in the description and photo #1 is very nice.

###############