Voting Comments
Record #: 22-B-07
Glossy Ibis
1st Round: 7-0
ACCEPT
|
1st Round |
| 07-11-2007. Stuts -- Accept Good documentation. Eliminated both the White-faced and hybrid |
| 13 July. Darren Clark -- Accept Well-written description eliminates White-faced Ibis. Key features Cliff notes are the eye color and description of where the blue line was on the face. |
| 07-14-2007. chuck trost -- Accept Excellent description of face and eye color. Season is right for breeding plumage and soft part color. |
| 07-14-2007. Dave Trochlell -- Accept Although Cliff wasn't able to view and describe the ibis's legs, he makes a compelling and convincing case for his identification. Well done! |
| 7-17-07. Carlisle -- Accept good description |
| 4 August 2007. Hardy -- Accept Report describes diagnostic fieldmarks of adult in alternate plumage. Timing fits other state records. |
| 9/11/2007. Charles Swift -- Accept Excellent description and identification of Glossy vs. White-faced very well described. (btw Why are we so biased against hybrids and isn't it worth recording them as well? They represent interesting phenomena, in this case providing additional evidence for a species expanding range.) |