Voting Comments
Species
Glaucous-winged Gull
Record #91-B-06
This record was previously included in IBRC #63-B-06. After the first round it was separated out of that record and given its own number.
1st Round: 6-1 (for first round comments see 63-B-06)
2nd Round: 7-0
|
2nd Round |
|
04-18-2009
Destription and photo diagnostic |
|
04-18-2009
Although not very clear, the images of this bird appear to be spot-on for an adult GWGU, with no apparent signs of hybridization. |
|
26 April 2009
Same comments as first round. |
|
06-27-2009
The adult surely looks like a GLGU to me and i vote to accept. |
|
07-07-2009
The adult bird discussed in original record #63-B-06 was well described and left little doubt of identity. Comparison to similar species was sufficient though the observer should have addressed elimination of potential hybrids. Regardless, I’m comfortable accepting this record. |
|
07/09/2009
Photos and description are good |
|
7/23/09
The photos and description of the adult GW Gull are convincing. |