Voting Comments
Record #: 37-B-06
Eurasian Collared-Dove
ACCEPT (7-0)
|
1st Round |
| 12-17-2006. Shirley Sturts -- Accept The darker primaries and darker under tail are field marks that eliminate the simlar Ringed Turtle-Doves. |
| 12-18-2006. chuck trost -- Accept The dark primaries and under-tail coverts were noted. |
| 12-21-2006. Carlisle -- Accept As with 19-B-06, possibly it would be better to require sufficient separation from Ringed Turtle Dove but ... |
| 12/26/06. Cliff Weisse -- Accept Relavent field marks included in description. |
| 01-05-2007. Dave Trochlell -- Accept I voted to accept this one on the strength of the accompanying report's details about the bird's dark undertail area - a critical feature for EUCD identification. Regretably missing in the report was information competing this candidate with Ringed Turtle-Dove, something that should be included in all Idaho EUCD reports. |
| 01-05-2007. dumroese -- Accept Acceptable level of detail provided. |
| 1/11/07. Charles Swift -- Accept Description adequate for species well established and expanding on the region. I don't see a need to eliminate Ringed Turtle-Dove with this knowledge,in fact I'm wondering why we are still reviewing records of the species from s. Idaho. |