Voting Comments
Record #: 6-A-06
Dickcissel
1st Round: (7-0)
|
1st Round |
| 12-10-2006. Shirley Sturts -- Accept Excellent photograph - good documentation - meets all the requirments of a first state record |
| 12/11/2006. Cliff Weisse -- Accept This record is particularly well documented. Excellent photos and a recording of the bird singing were nice additions to the written reports. |
| 12-11-2006. chuck trost -- Accept Multiple observers, good write-ups and photos, and I saw the bird. |
| 12-12-06. Carlisle -- Accept looks good |
| 12-13-2006. Dave Trochlell -- Accept It's a pleasure to accept a record that is as well documented - and incontrovertible - as this one. This was one species that I expected would show up in Idaho some day, given that it nests in Montana and has made at least one appearance in every state surrounding the Gem State. |
| 01-02-2007. dumroese -- Accept The descriptions were comprehensive. The photos were excellent. I couldn't get the audio to play, but the photos alone are sufficient evidence of this species. |
| 1/16/07. Charles Swift -- Accept There is no doubt about this based on the photo and description. The song seems a bit atypical to me although it I haven't heard the species for a while. A question: Who found this bird?? It's not clear from the report and that is something that probably should be included (in any report for that matter). |