Voting Comments
Record #: 10-B-97
Brant
ACCEPT (7-0)
|
1st Round |
| 01-10-2007 Shirley Sturts -- Accept good documentation and photo Several experienced observers |
| 1/11/07. Cliff Weisse -- Accept Documentation for this record includes excellent written descriptions and a good photo that verifies field marks included in description. |
| 1/11/07. Charles Swift -- Accept Good supporting details and photos. I also saw this bird (it was the year I moved to Idaho). I wonder if anyone is going to speculate as to what race of "Balck" Brant this is?? |
| 1-11-07. Carlisle -- Accept good reports and photo |
| 01-12-2007. Dave Trochlell -- Accept I accept this candidate as a record with no reservations. |
| 02-12-2007. chuck trost -- Accept Multiple observers, no bands, good descriptions. |
| 18 April 2007. Hardy -- Accept I don't know what other species this could be confused with. I agree that the white-tipped coverts indicate this is a subadult. The high collar and muddy belly color are compatible with B. b. nigricans; description in Svingen's report more definitive than photo. |