Voting Comments
Record #: 70-B-06
Black Scoter
ACCEPT (7-0)
|
1st Round |
| 01-11-2007 Shirley Sturts -- Accept Good Description, additional experience observers |
| 1/11/07. Cliff Weisse -- Accept Good description includes relavent field marks. Spencer also did a good job eliminating other species. |
| 1-11-07. Carlisle -- Accept Good, detailed report (& I saw the bird). One thing: I thought that Spencer reported on IBLE that the other 2 folks listed on the report saw 2 individual BLSCs on 11-19. If so, this would be an important addition. |
| 01-12-2007. Dave Trochlell -- Accept I accept this candidate as a record with no reservations, and express my appreciation for a very good report. |
| 1/19/07. Charles Swift -- Accept Nice descriptionj by Spencer. I also remember seeing a post by Jay confirming the sighting. |
| 02-12-2007. chuck trost -- Accept Good description, and appropriate time of year. |
| 23 April 2007. Hardy -- Accept Description, especially of face pattern, eliminates all other species except Surf Scoter. Bill shape as described is consistent with Black and not Surf Scoter. Description is of female or immature Black Scoter. |